Gerrard St. Bakery
635 Gerrard St E, Toronto, ON M4M 1Y2, Canada
Phone: (416) 465-4567
Website: https://www.gerrardstreetbakery.com/
Gerrard St. Bakery in Toronto is a 4.6-star Bakery restaurant with 365 Google reviews, known for Butter Tarts and Key Lime Pie.
Why we love it
- Bakery with classic Canadian and international treats
- Freshly baked goods, friendly staff, wide selection
- Counter service with custom order options
- Bakery with classic Canadian and international treats
- Located nearby
- Freshly baked goods, friendly staff, wide selection
- Counter service with custom order options
What to Order
Butter Tarts
These iconic Canadian treats feature a flaky pastry crust filled with a sweet, gooey butter filling, often considered the best in the city.
"The butter tarts are absolutely to die for. And I’ve eaten A LOT of butter tarts. Really, they are the best."
Susan Quinn
Key Lime Pie
A perfectly tart and refreshing pie with a delicious graham cracker crust, ideal for a special occasion.
"Special ordered a key lime pie for my partners birthday and Gerard St Bakery hit it out of the park! Really good graham cracker crust and perfectly tart."
Jodie Grieve
Lemon Tart
This tart offers a delightful balance of sweet and sour, making it a sophisticated and enjoyable dessert.
"The lemon tart was perfectly balanced. Not overly sweet or sour."
Stan
Chocolate Cake
A rich and decadent cake that is both delicious and visually appealing, perfect for celebrations.
"We have had the chocolate cake and the buttertart cake here at different times. They were both delicious."
C k
Brownie
An incredibly rich and perfectly textured chocolate brownie, a must-try for chocolate lovers.
"The brownie was incredibly rich and had perfect texture. Both were the best I've had!"
Stan
Inside Scoop
- Consider pre-ordering larger cakes, especially for special occasions.
- For optimal flavor, allow cakes to come to room temperature for about two hours before eating.
- The staff are known for being exceptionally warm and friendly.
- They are a reliable spot for last-minute holiday pie purchases.
- Don't miss their empanadas for a savory option.