Maisy’s Pearl Oyster Bar
342 Barton St E, Hamilton, ON L8L 2X7, Canada
Phone: (289) 389-1870
Website: https://www.maisyspearl.com/
Maisy’s Pearl Oyster Bar in Hamilton is a 4.9-star restaurant with 197 Google reviews, known for Oysters and Lobster Roll.
Why we love it
- Seafood with East Coast influence
- Intimate setting, engaging experience, cozy vibes
- Attentive service with passionate hosts
- Seafood with East Coast influence
- Located nearby
- Intimate setting, engaging experience, cozy vibes
- Attentive service with passionate hosts
What to Order
Oysters
A diverse selection of fresh oysters from various regions, often chosen by the knowledgeable staff, served with unique accompaniments like grated horseradish.
"Absolutely incredible oysters — and so much more!!!"
Helen
Lobster Roll
A warm, standout lobster roll that many reviewers compare favorably to those found in traditional East Coast seafood destinations.
"My son had a lobster roll which was better than some he had in Nova Scotia."
lorene welch
Crab Cakes
These crab cakes are praised for being pure crab with no filler, often served with a side salad that reviewers rave about.
"FYI - the crab cakes were the BEST ever and the side salad tried to steal the show!"
Dave Behiel
Shrimp Ceviche
A fabulously dressed and seasoned shrimp ceviche, served with homemade tortillas that transport diners to Mexico.
"Cannot recommend the shrimp ceviche enough - fabulously dressed and seasoned with homemade tortillas like no other. It felt like being transported to Mexico."
Bruna Aguiar
Grilled Octopus
A perfectly cooked octopus dish, noted for its ideal texture and flavor.
"The octopus was cooked perfectly and the fried clams were little drops of heaven."
Alex Kaschuba
Nan's Famous Butter Tart
A beloved dessert, often served warm with vanilla ice cream, reminiscent of homemade quality and made with love.
"Before I wrap this up I need to urge you to finish off your meal with Nans famous butter tart that is easy to tell it was made with love."
Alex Kaschuba
Inside Scoop
- Reservations are highly recommended due to the small, intimate seating capacity of about 20 people.
- Allow the staff to select a variety of oysters for you; their knowledge is a highlight of the experience.
- The owners, David and Sasha, are known for their passionate engagement and welcoming hospitality.
- Consider visiting on a Tuesday for their oyster special (12 oysters + 2 beers for $40).
- On Saturdays, you might enjoy live music from a saxophone player.