Nicey's Eatery
2290 Markham Rd, Scarborough, ON M1W 2W4, Canada
Phone: (416) 321-9991
Nicey's Eatery in Scarborough is a 4.3-star restaurant with 1,451 Google reviews, known for Oxtail and Jerk Chicken.
Why we love it
- Caribbean with Jamaican influence
- Generous portions, friendly staff, lively atmosphere
- Casual dining with quick service
- Caribbean with Jamaican influence
- Located nearby
- Generous portions, friendly staff, lively atmosphere
- Casual dining with quick service
What to Order
Oxtail
Tender, flavorful oxtail served with rice and peas and mixed greens, praised for its balanced taste and delicious gravy.
"The oxtail is really good. My friend brought me here promising a great meal. I was skeptical. However, the favour was balanced, the meat was tender, and the gravy was delicious."
Frank Newhart
Jerk Chicken
Spicy and authentic jerk chicken, available in dark meat, known for its delicious flavor and perfect seasoning.
"I tried the jerk chicken today and was told that the jerk is spicy. I loved it. I would go back to see if the regular jerk is as spicy."
David Chen
Fried Chicken
Crispy and flavorful fried chicken, a popular choice among groups and consistently rated highly.
"My family tried the oxtail, fried chicken, jerk chicken and jerk pork. You can tell everything is made with care."
Clem Mp
Curry Goat
Tender and perfectly seasoned curry goat, often served with white rice and steamed vegetables.
"Also got a Curry goat and white rice amd Steamed vegetable. Goat was tender and seasoned perfectly."
Orin Monize
Ackee and Saltfish
A traditional dish with a clean, balanced flavor, noted for its healthy preparation and generous portions.
"It was so full of flavour, with the perfect balance of everything on the plate. I ordered the large, and it was generous enough to last me for both lunch and dinner."
Sarah Andrade
Spicy Beef Patty
A hot, flavorful patty with a perfect meat-to-gravy ratio and a buttery, flaky crust.
"It was served hot, packed with delicious flavour, the perfect meat-to-gravy ratio, and that buttery, flaky crust we all want in a good patty."
Sarah Andrade
Inside Scoop
- The outdoor patio with BBQ and bar service is a great spot during spring/summer.
- Expect a lively atmosphere with reggae music playing in the background.
- They offer a rewards program, so ask about it when you order.
- Food can take some time for takeout, but it's always super fresh.
- Service can be inconsistent, with some reviewers noting long waits or inattentive staff.