Shay Ristorante
1055 Yonge St, Toronto, ON M4W 2L2, Canada
Phone: (416) 546-1444
Website: https://shayristorante.com/
Shay Ristorante in Toronto is a 4.8-star restaurant with 106 Google reviews, known for Focaccia with Baglio Rocca Olive Oil and Kale Salad (Cavolo Ricco).
Why we love it
- Italian with refined, authentic flavors
- Located near Near Roxborough St W and Paul Hanlon
- Elegant and inviting, London-meets-New York energy, chic Milanese ambiance
- Attentive service with genuine warmth and hospitality
- Italian with refined, authentic flavors
- Located near Near Roxborough St W and Paul Hanlon
- Elegant and inviting, London-meets-New York energy, chic Milanese ambiance
- Attentive service with genuine warmth and hospitality
What to Order
Focaccia with Baglio Rocca Olive Oil
Warm, fluffy focaccia served with their exclusive, highly praised Baglio Rocca olive oil. A perfect start to the meal.
"We started with the focaccia and their exclusive Baglio Rocca olive oil, which was the perfect way to kick off the evening."
Adrianna Ho
Kale Salad (Cavolo Ricco)
A standout salad that is consistently highlighted for its freshness and flavor, making it a must-order green dish.
"The crispy rice was a lovely dish, the kale salad is an absolute must, and the vodka pasta was to die for."
Adrianna Ho
Spicy Vodka Rigatoni / Fusilli Pasta in Tomato Vodka Sauce
A rich and flavorful pasta dish with just the right amount of kick, often described as a highlight of the menu.
"My highlight dish was the spicy vodka rigatoni - it is my favourite pasta of all time and Shay took it to a whole other level."
Julia Berry
Tortellini
A well-executed pasta dish, praised for its delicious taste and perfect preparation.
"We had the beef carpaccio, tortellini, carbonara, and branzino, every dish was beyond delicious."
Anne Morrone
Branzino
A perfectly cooked fish dish that consistently receives high praise for its flavor and preparation.
"Everything we ordered was delicious, but the kale salad and branzino were definitely our favourites."
Alanna Moness
Pistachio Basque Cheesecake
A unique and delicious dessert, often served with raspberry cream, providing a perfect sweet ending to the meal.
"We finished with the pistachio Basque cheesecake, which was the perfect ending to an already amazing meal."
Adrianna Ho
Olive Oil Martini
A unique and fantastic cocktail that stands out among the drink offerings.
"Every item we got we finished and same goes for the drinks - the olive oil martini was especially fantastic."
Bella Krys
Inside Scoop
- The atmosphere is a major draw, perfect for special occasions or an elegant night out.
- Service can be inconsistent; some guests report slow service or missed details.
- The Carbonara and Lobster Risotto have been noted as overwhelmingly salty by some, so proceed with caution or ask about salt levels.
- If celebrating a birthday, be aware that it might not be acknowledged by the staff.
- Consider sharing multiple pasta dishes to experience more of the menu.