Tony G’s Pizzeria
30 John St N, Hamilton, ON L8R 1G9, Canada
Phone: (905) 524-1010
Tony G’s Pizzeria in Hamilton is a 4.8-star Pizza restaurant with 1,471 Google reviews, known for NY Pepperoni Slice and O-G Hammer-Town Deluxe Pizza.
Why we love it
- New York-style pizza with classic Italian influence
- Massive slices, friendly staff, quality ingredients
- Dine-in or takeout with cash-only payment
- New York-style pizza with classic Italian influence
- Located nearby
- Massive slices, friendly staff, quality ingredients
- Dine-in or takeout with cash-only payment
What to Order
NY Pepperoni Slice
A classic New York-style pepperoni slice, known for its generous size, crispy pepperoni, and perfect crust.
"The pepperoni slice might be the best I’ve ever had. So fresh. So tasty!!! Amazing!!!"
Jamie Petrie
O-G Hammer-Town Deluxe Pizza
A flavorful pizza crafted with fresh, high-quality ingredients, often ordered as a half-and-half option.
"The O-G was created with fresh flavorful ingredients that kept us wanting more."
Chris Millward
The Bianco Pizza
A "sleeper hit" white pizza, praised for its very tasty and masterful preparation.
"Ordered what might be a sleeper hit....The Bianco. What else can you really say.....but very very tasty, another fine masterpeice."
Chris Millward
Anchor Bar Wings
Wings that authentically replicate the taste of the famous Anchor Bar in Buffalo, a perfect side to your pizza.
"And with regards to the Anchor Bar wings, well let's just say they tasted just like those from the Anchor Bar in Buffalo......Beautiful!"
Chris Millward
The Big Sexy Pizza
A new menu item that has quickly become a favorite, described as "to die for" with excellent presentation.
"I Ordered thr big sexy a nee pizza on their menu and it literally was to die for."
Natasha Lumsdon-Young
Inside Scoop
- Be prepared for cash-only transactions, as they do not accept cards.
- Pizzas are massive; a medium here is often equivalent to a large elsewhere.
- Expect friendly and accommodating service, often from the owner himself.
- While pizza is generally excellent, some report occasional issues with sogginess or undercooked crust, so consider requesting "well done."
- Ordering ahead might not guarantee your pizza starts cooking immediately upon order, so factor in potential wait times.