Best Italian Restaurants in Southwestern Ontario (Nov 2026)
10 curated restaurants with up-to-date reviews, signature dishes & insider tips
Last updated November 22, 2026
Ranked by the Inside Scoop Score
How this is scored
- National accolades — Michelin, Canada's 100 Best, World's 50 Best and the like, weighted by how prestigious the honour is. The biggest driver.
- How widely it's recommended — how many trusted "best-of" lists feature the restaurant.
- Rating — its Google rating, adjusted for how many reviews back it up.
These add together into the score. The number isn't out of 100 — it's a points total, so the rank beside it is the quickest read.
| # | Restaurant | Scoop Score | Awards | Google Rating | What to Order | Address |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Boa Bakery | 153 | 4.7 ★250 reviews | Sourdough Pizza, Pastéis de Nata (Portuguese Tarts) | 3200 Hwy 56, Binbrook, ON L0R 1C0 | |
| 2 | Maipai | 137 | 4.8 ★1,794 reviews | Soy Caramel Wings, Dill Pickle Pizza | 631 Barton St E, Hamilton, ON L8L 3A1 | |
| 3 | Tony G’s Pizzeria | 135 | 4.8 ★1,471 reviews | NY Pepperoni Slice, O-G Hammer-Town Deluxe Pizza | 30 John St N, Hamilton, ON L8R 1G9 | |
| 4 | Born & Raised | 132 | 4.4 ★1,206 reviews | Wood Fired Pizza (various), Nonna's Meatballs | 224 James St N, Hamilton, ON L8R 2L3 | |
| 5 | Cowabunga Pizzeria - Take Out Only | 111 | 4.2 ★1,322 reviews | Our Marg, 1UP | 536 Upper Wellington St, Hamilton, ON L9A 3P5 | |
| 6 | Roma Bakery & Deli | 66 | 4.5 ★955 reviews | Slab Pizza (Bread Pizza), Venetian Cannoli | 233 Barton St, Stoney Creek, ON L8E 2K3 | |
| 7 | Valentino's Restaurant - Westdale | 66 | 4.4 ★1,054 reviews | Lasagna, Panzerotti (Fried) | 824 King St W, Hamilton, ON L8S 1K3 | |
| 8 | Lê Bella Pizza (Bella Pizza) | 63 | 4.4 ★817 reviews | Pizza (General), Chicken Shawarma Pizza | 455 Barton St E, Hamilton, ON L8L 2Y6 | |
| 9 | Carlo's Pizza & Grill | 63 | 4.5 ★697 reviews | Shawarma Sandwich, Pizza | 10-1970 Rymal Rd E, Hannon, ON L0R 1P0 | |
| 10 | Cavallo Nero | 62 | 4.3 ★783 reviews | Rigatoni a la Vodka, Chicken Picatta | 370 Wilson St E, Ancaster, ON L9G 2C2 |
Ranked by the Inside Scoop Score — editorial accolades, recommendation breadth, and verified diner reviews.









