Best Italian Restaurants in Toronto (May 2026)

$$$ · Oakville

4.2 ★

What to order Tuna Tartare / Tuna Crudo, Burrata, Agnolotti

$$ · Toronto

What to order Pepperoni Pizza (Windsor Style), Pizza Slices, Canned Mushrooms (on pizza)

$$ · Toronto

What to order Weekly Rotating House-Made Pastas, Lasagna, Po Bianco bread

$$ · Toronto

What to order Pizza (general), Carbonara Pizza, Sausage Pizza

Toronto

4.7 ★

What to order Enzo, Schiacciata bread sandwiches

$$$ · Toronto

4.6 ★

What to order Carbonara, Mushroom Agnolotti, Brussel Sprouts

Toronto

4.4 ★

What to order Bar Ardo Burger, Linguine with wild shrimp, Oysters

Toronto

4.4 ★

What to order Tomato Tramezzini, Chicken Liver & Caviar Maritozzi, Scallops Rockefeller

$$ · Toronto

What to order Pizza, Spaghetti Pesto, Rigatoni

$$ · Toronto

4.6 ★

What to order Meatballs, Crown Cacio e Pepe, Rigatoni with Fennel

$$ · Toronto

4.5 ★

What to order Pepperoni Pizza, Crust Monsieur, Garlic Dip

Toronto

What to order Bello Slice, Pepperoni Slice, Portabella Slice

$ · Toronto

What to order Cheese Panzerotti, Pizza

Toronto

What to order Ravioli du Dauphine, Rigatoni alla Vodka, Steak and Eggs

What to order Pizza al Taglia, Margarita Pizza, Dolce Pizza

Toronto

4.6 ★

What to order Mackerel Crostini, Duck Agnolotti, Braised Beef Cheek Cavatelli

Toronto

4.7 ★

What to order Black Truffle Pasta (Spaghettoni), Black Cod, Branzino

Toronto

What to order Mozzarella Sticks, Caesar Salad, Garlic Bread

$$ · Toronto

What to order Truffle Mushroom Pizza (Truff Guy/Truffghi), The Canadian, No Name

$$$$ · Toronto

4.5 ★

What to order Signature Tasting Menu, Wine Pairing, Bread Service

$$$ · Toronto

4.3 ★

What to order Garlic White Wine Clam Pasta, Seafood Linguini, Bruschetta

$$ · Toronto

4.4 ★

What to order Bucatini all’ Amatriciana, Rigatoni, Truffle Pasta (Agnolotti or similar)

$$ · Toronto

4.7 ★

What to order Fresh Pasta (daily specials), Ravioli (Spinach Ricotta or Pumpkin), Tiramisu

$$ · Toronto

What to order Octopus starter, Gnocchi alla Gorgonzola, Lasagna

Toronto

4.5 ★

What to order Focaccia, Vegan Meatballs, Rigatoni Bolognese

$$ · Toronto

What to order Giant Meatball, Focaccia, Pappardelle

$$$ · Toronto

4.6 ★

What to order Beef Tartare, Grilled Octopus, Veal Cheek Ragu

Toronto

What to order Spicy Pepp Pizza, Margherita Pizza, Daily Special Pizza

Toronto

What to order Pepperoni Pizza, Mushroom Pizza, Vodka Sauce Pizza

$$ · Toronto

4.3 ★

What to order Mafalde ai Funghi (Mushroom Pasta), Veal Schnitzel, Tiramisu

$$ · Toronto

What to order Mafalde ai Funghi (Mushroom Pasta), Pappardelle Wagyu Ragu, Arancini

$$$ · Toronto

4.3 ★

What to order 100 Layer Lasagna, Vodka Pasta with Nduja, Grilled Chicken

5 locations in Toronto, Thornhill

What to order Frank's Best, Fried Wings, Garlic Fingers

Toronto

What to order Braised Short Ribs, Gnocchi, Meat Pizzas

$ · 7 locations in Toronto, North York, Etobicoke

What to order Killer Bee Pizza, Vodka Pizza, Margherita Pizza

Toronto

4.2 ★

What to order Spaghetti all’Amatriciana, Beet Salad, Crudo

Toronto

4.4 ★

What to order Indivia e Pera (Endive Salad), Crudo di Orata (Japanese Sea Bream), Focaccia di Recco

3 locations in Toronto, Oakville

4.2 ★

What to order Whipped Ricotta, Fun Guy Pizza, Bacon Alfredo Pizza

$$ · Toronto

What to order Wood-Fired Pizza (Neapolitan style), Tagliatelle Alla Pescatora, Gnocchi

$$ · Toronto

4.7 ★

What to order Vodka Pizza, Burrata Marinara, Spicy Salami Pizza

$$ · 3 locations in North York, Toronto

What to order Margherita Pizza, Arancini, Gnocchi

$$ · Toronto

What to order Pizza, Stuffed Crust Pizza, Pasta

York

4.3 ★

What to order Lasagna Bolognese, Tiramisu Soft Serve, Rigatoni Ragu

$$$ · Mississauga

4.1 ★

What to order Flaming Parmigiano Wheel Pasta, Gnocchi, Pizza

$$ · Toronto

What to order Spicy Spring pizza, Build your own vegan and gluten free deep dish pizza

$$$$ · 2 locations in Toronto, Oakville

4.3 ★

What to order Rigatoni alla Vodka, Lasagna, Calamari

$$ · Toronto

What to order Mr. Hand, Pancetta Pizza, Lil' Cabbagetown

Toronto

4.6 ★

What to order ELORA ST MARTIN’S STRIPLOIN, CRUDO DI TONNO, 100-EGG PASTA

$$$$ · Toronto

4.3 ★

What to order Rigatoni alla Vodka, Tagliatelle Bolognese, Tiramisu

Toronto

4.7 ★

What to order "Chicken" Fillet with Marsala Sauce, Tiramisu, Smash Burger

$$ · Toronto

What to order Rigatoni, Pesto Cream Spaghetti, Calamari

$$ · 4 locations in Toronto

What to order Wood-fired Pizzas, Spinach Ravioli stuffed with Braised Beef, Tonnarelli alla Norcina

Toronto

4.9 ★

What to order Carbonara Pasta, Cacio Pepe Raviolo Uovo, Seafood Bucatini (with Nova Scotia Snow Crab)

$$ · Toronto

What to order Lasagna, Mafalde ai Funghi, Indivia Salad

$$ · Toronto

What to order Wood-fired Pizza, Pasta Dishes, Arancini

$$$ · Toronto

What to order Pappardelle, Braised Beef Cheek, Pinci al Sugo di Cinghiale

Toronto

4.6 ★

What to order Burrata with Focaccia, Mafaldine Pasta, Steak Tartare

$$ · Toronto

What to order Tasting Menu ($75 shared), Hokkaido Scallop w/ aguachile & strawberry, Branzino